I’ve been really excited about Me and Earl and the Dying Girl since the beginning and a couple days ago I finally had a chance to watch it. The film was said to be smart and funny and original so my expectations were quite high – and I didn’t need to be disappointed! Based on Jesse Andrews’ novel (and screenplay) Alfonso Gomez-Rejon directed the movie whose work I was familiar with from American Horror Story. This film was quite different from that of course but it had the same really strong atmosphere as his other directorial works.
The movie is about the friendship of three high schoolers – although Greg only starts to hang out with Rachel because his mum is making him when they learn that she’s been diagnosed with leukemia. But then they become real friends and that is when their story gets doomed. It is kind of a coming-of-age story but more than that – luckily most adolescents don’t have to face sad and serious situations like this.
The film is narrated by Greg who makes movies with his friend or – how he prefers to call Earl – co-worker and though we see everything from his viewpoint we learn quite a lot about him throughout the story. Things that he doesn’t want to recognize or admit and wants to cover with never-ending smart and witty comments. He keeps talking about what would happen if this was a touching romantic story, but then he always reminds us that this is not. Which I think is just half the truth – because it is touching. Not in the original, you’ll-cry-yourself-to-sleep way, but in a more bittersweet, unique way.
I love how independent cinema doesn’t feel the need to tell you constantly exactly what is happening, what are the characters feeling in every moment. It makes stories much more real for me. I’ve been lucky enough to not have to fear for my friend’s life but as I was watching this movie I could tell that my reactions and feelings would be like Greg’s.
SPOILERS!
There is a scene where Rachel tells Greg about her decision to stop treatment which I found amazingly powerful. There’s no music and no movement, just two kids and their feelings. I especially loved the setting – seeing Rachel’s crying face in the front and hearing Greg’s anger (and fear) while he stays in the back of the frame. It made me feel the distance in that moment between them. And made me think about how selfish we are when it comes to our loved ones. If we could turn off our feelings we could see that they are in pain, that they are just making logical decisions. But it hurts too much and we can’t think with their heads, we just want to save ourselves from suffering.
Me and Earl and the Dying Girl also made me realize that I can still be quite naive. When Greg told us Rachel will get better, he promised she won’t die, I believed him. Even when she was really sick I wanted to believe him. Which was naive of me but maybe it’s not necessarily a bad thing. I prefer to think of it as hopefulness which I think is really important in tough times. I wasn’t surprised by the ending though, but it was still sad.
SPOILERS END!
All in all I found Me and Earl and the Dying Girl a great coming-of-age movie which can teach us a lot about ourselves. About feelings, tough decisions in a really honest, true, powerful way. It is sad naturally, but at the same time it was able to remain funny and kind with lovely settings and music and had a quite feelgood atmosphere. And with amazing performances – especially from Thomas Mann (Greg) and Olivia Cooke (Rachel). Definately recommended to everyone who doesn’t mind an emotional but not at all cheesy movie!
And this is the part where my writing ends